As the holidays approach, school buzzes with activity. Homecomings, basketball season, holiday concerts and celebrations, and many other things that are sure to divert your attention from the yearbook’s theme and onto other matters that seem more pressing. This time of year is a whirlwind of grading, deadlines, shopping and celebrations. In the middle of the excitement, yearbook staff members seem to become overwhelmed and lose track of the yearbook’s theme.
A strong theme gives the yearbook its identity, bringing the sections together, guiding the storytelling and setting the tone for the publication as a whole. However, maintaining consistency is a challenge when schedules tighten and responsibilities multiply. Here are four effective strategies that are sure to keep your theme alive from cover to final caption:
-
BE THEME INTENTIONAL: Embed your theme in all coverage
Use everyday content to drive your theme, ensuring that staff reporters incorporate the theme into their interview questions. By doing this, you allow students and educators to reflect on the theme through quotes and feature stories. Photographers are even tasked to take images that visually support the theme by choosing consistent angles and lighting motifs that lend themselves to the theme as well.
For example, our school used the theme “Just Say That” for its 2025 yearbook, which addressed many misconceptions people have about the school and adapted them into more positive messages. The students focused on individual coverage that spotlighted students who had persevered through trauma and were willing to tell their story – Just Say That. The photography for the individual coverage included moody motifs that added to the story and theme.
-
HIT THE BREAKS: Stop, review, repeat to maintain consistency
With tight deadlines, holiday distractions and less-than-favorable turnaround times, it’s easy for copy and design elements to drift away from the staff’s original concept(s). The key to maintaining consistency here is to create natural STOP points for editorial checking to ensure all of the pages remain on theme. REVIEW the design and copy for consistency throughout. Finally, REPEAT the process by developing an editorial process even at this stage of the game will benefit your final project in an immeasurable way. Look for small inconsistencies now before they become habitual and major.
-
PIN IT TO WIN IT: Create a theme reference board inside the classroom
If you’re like me, you hate tons of things stuck to your walls, but in a yearbook, it is necessary. The theme board is a visual reminder of the concept(s) for the year. Keep the color palette and interesting pairings posted along with fonts and samples of how the fonts should work together, even including design inspirations from magazines and advertisements. Ensure that you include visual anchors that help guide the design, and they help boost motivation and inspiration about what a spread could be within the theme.
-
GET SOME R & R: After the break, revisit and re-energize the theme
After a little rest and relaxation during the break, the workflow can really be interrupted. Many staffs find it difficult to regain the momentum. Advisers and staff must set aside some time after the break to conduct a theme reset, which helps to reestablish consistency. Editors should highlight key elements of the theme for the staff and allow staff members to be a part of the conversation by bringing in aspects of the theme that they feel have been lost over time. This reset can truly reignite the fire and excitement around your theme.
Winter activities and looming deadlines do make it hard to keep your theme alive, and doing the work to fully incorporate it may feel like just another thing on your already full to-do list, but with intention, planning and consistent reminders, the theme can remain a guiding force to your book. By doing these four simple things, your theme will live from cover to cover.
